City of Buffalo / Police Internal Affairs Division / Police Lieutenant

Job-title file

Police Lieutenant

Enforce laws and maintain public safety — patrol, respond to incidents, investigate crimes, and make arrests.

9 employees hold this title in Police Internal Affairs Division. Median total compensation for the role is $144,143, above the department median of $144,143.

Employees: 9
Role median: $144,143
Agency median: $144,143
Comparison: Above

What the records show

Role pay distribution

Pay distribution for this role

$8,667$211,289+

How total compensation varies among the 9 people in this role. Even for one job title, pay differs with seniority, step, overtime, and tenure. Each bar is a pay range; the far-right bar collects the highest earners.

Record list

Employees with this title

Highest-paid first / page 1

Louis Kelly

Police Lieutenant/Police Internal Affairs Division

2025 total comp

$216,467

Sub-department: PUBLIC SAFETY
Base pay: $33,360
Overtime: $64,067
Other pay: $119,040
Benefits: $0
Total compensation: $216,467

Source-specific fields

Employeeid: 72900

Louis Kelly holds the role of Police Lieutenant at Police Internal Affairs Division within Public Safety. In 2025, their total compensation was $216,467.

Jon Kokotajlo

Police Lieutenant/Police Internal Affairs Division

2026 total comp

$184,109

Sub-department: PUBLIC SAFETY
Base pay: $89,432
Overtime: $68,200
Other pay: $26,477
Benefits: $0
Total compensation: $184,109

Source-specific fields

Employeeid: 168233

At Police Internal Affairs Division, Jon Kokotajlo serves as a Police Lieutenant within Public Safety. Their 2026 pay totaled $184,109.

Bradford Pitts

Police Lieutenant/Police Internal Affairs Division

2026 total comp

$172,121

Sub-department: PUBLIC SAFETY
Base pay: $89,694
Overtime: $56,881
Other pay: $25,546
Benefits: $0
Total compensation: $172,121

Source-specific fields

Employeeid: 169639

Bradford Pitts is a Police Lieutenant at Police Internal Affairs Division within Public Safety. 2026 total compensation came to $172,121.

Karin Turello

Police Lieutenant/Police Internal Affairs Division

2026 total comp

$160,094

Sub-department: PUBLIC SAFETY
Base pay: $85,812
Overtime: $46,185
Other pay: $28,097
Benefits: $0
Total compensation: $160,094

Source-specific fields

Employeeid: 172553

Karin Turello works as a Police Lieutenant for Police Internal Affairs Division within Public Safety. Karin earned $160,094 in 2026.

Michael Farley

Police Lieutenant/Police Internal Affairs Division

2026 total comp

$144,143

Sub-department: PUBLIC SAFETY
Base pay: $92,894
Overtime: $28,235
Other pay: $23,015
Benefits: $0
Total compensation: $144,143

Source-specific fields

Employeeid: 168216

Michael Farley is a Police Lieutenant at Police Internal Affairs Division within Public Safety. 2026 total compensation came to $144,143.

Aaron Mc Dowell

Police Lieutenant/Police Internal Affairs Division

2026 total comp

$140,937

Sub-department: PUBLIC SAFETY
Base pay: $95,464
Overtime: $27,129
Other pay: $18,345
Benefits: $0
Total compensation: $140,937

Source-specific fields

Employeeid: 173058

Aaron Mc Dowell works as a Police Lieutenant for Police Internal Affairs Division within Public Safety. Aaron earned $140,937 in 2026.

Patrick Meegan

Police Lieutenant/Police Internal Affairs Division

2026 total comp

$128,159

Sub-department: PUBLIC SAFETY
Base pay: $92,317
Overtime: $16,475
Other pay: $19,368
Benefits: $0
Total compensation: $128,159

Source-specific fields

Employeeid: 173661

At Police Internal Affairs Division, Patrick Meegan serves as a Police Lieutenant within Public Safety. Their 2026 pay totaled $128,159.

Michael Alberti

Police Lieutenant/Police Internal Affairs Division

2026 total comp

$59,160

Sub-department: PUBLIC SAFETY
Base pay: $0
Overtime: $59,160
Other pay: $0
Benefits: $0
Total compensation: $59,160

Source-specific fields

Employeeid: 2560

Michael Alberti is a Police Lieutenant at Police Internal Affairs Division within Public Safety. 2026 total compensation came to $59,160.

Stacy Lewis-Beauford

Police Lieutenant/Police Internal Affairs Division

2024 total comp

$8,667

Sub-department: PUBLIC SAFETY
Base pay: $0
Overtime: $224
Other pay: $8,443
Benefits: $0
Total compensation: $8,667

Source-specific fields

Employeeid: 81100

Stacy Lewis-Beauford works as a Police Lieutenant for Police Internal Affairs Division within Public Safety. Stacy earned $8,667 in 2024.