New York City / Hunter College High School / Substitute Teacher

Job-title file

Substitute Teacher

Plan and deliver instruction, assess student progress, and develop curriculum.

63 employees hold this title in Hunter College High School. Median total compensation for the role is $14,615, below the department median of $26,219.

Employees: 63
Total payroll: $1.9M
Role median: $14,615
Agency median: $26,219
Comparison: Below

What the records show

Role pay distribution

Pay distribution for this role

$498$95,745+

Hover a bar for its range; click to filter the list below.

How total compensation varies among the 63 people in this role. Even for one job title, pay differs with seniority, step, overtime, and tenure. Each bar is a pay range; the far-right bar collects the highest earners.

Compare jurisdictions

Substitute Teacher beyond New York City

This role is reported in 8 jurisdictions. In New York City, the median of $14,615 ranks #2 of 8. See Substitute Teacher across all of New York City →

Highest-paying jurisdictions for this role

Seattle Public Schools

$113,965 · 42

City of Boston

$6,737 · 327

Davis School District, Utah

$4,184 · 280

$3,525 · 24,509

$2,575 · 4,586

$854 · 18

$20 · 896

Median total compensation for comparable Substitute Teacherroles in other jurisdictions. Titles are matched by normalized name across sources, not identical job classification, and pay is not cost-of-living adjusted. Each bar links to that jurisdiction’s page for the role.

Record list

Employees with this title

Page 1

Natasha Gwirceman

Substitute Teacher/Hunter College High School

2025 total comp

$9,665

Base pay: $9,665
Overtime: $0
Other pay: $0
Benefits: $0
Total compensation: $9,665
Hire date: 2023-05-26
Pay basis: Hourly
Work city: Manhattan

Source-specific fields

Base Salary: $199
Leave Status as of June 30: Active
Overtime Hours: 0
Payroll Number: 470
Regular Hours: 48.5

Natasha Gwirceman works as a Substitute Teacher for Hunter College High School based in Manhattan. Their tenure dates to 2023, about 2 years. Natasha earned $9,665 in 2025.

Francine Winiker

Substitute Teacher/Hunter College High School

2025 total comp

$8,967

Base pay: $8,967
Overtime: $0
Other pay: $0
Benefits: $0
Total compensation: $8,967
Hire date: 2024-02-01
Pay basis: Hourly
Work city: Manhattan

Source-specific fields

Base Salary: $199
Leave Status as of June 30: Active
Overtime Hours: 0
Payroll Number: 470
Regular Hours: 45

Francine Winiker works as a Substitute Teacher for Hunter College High School based in Manhattan. They have served since 2024 (about a year). Francine earned $8,967 in 2025.

Natalie Wagner

Substitute Teacher/Hunter College High School

2025 total comp

$8,469

Base pay: $8,469
Overtime: $0
Other pay: $0
Benefits: $0
Total compensation: $8,469
Hire date: 2023-05-08
Pay basis: Hourly
Work city: Manhattan
Middle name: C

Source-specific fields

Base Salary: $199
Leave Status as of June 30: Active
Overtime Hours: 0
Payroll Number: 470
Regular Hours: 42.5

Natalie Wagner works as a Substitute Teacher for Hunter College High School based in Manhattan. Hired in 2023, they have about 2 years of service. Natalie earned $8,469 in 2025.

Danielle Heslin

Substitute Teacher/Hunter College High School

2025 total comp

$8,270

Base pay: $8,270
Overtime: $0
Other pay: $0
Benefits: $0
Total compensation: $8,270
Hire date: 2023-11-09
Pay basis: Hourly
Work city: Manhattan
Middle name: A

Source-specific fields

Base Salary: $199
Leave Status as of June 30: Active
Overtime Hours: 0
Payroll Number: 470
Regular Hours: 41.5

Danielle Heslin works as a Substitute Teacher for Hunter College High School based in Manhattan. Hired in 2023, they have about 2 years of service. Danielle earned $8,270 in 2025.

Deborah ModelMay be multiple

Substitute Teacher/Hunter College High School

2025 total comp

$7,524

Hire date: 2024-09-26
Pay basis: Hourly
Work city: Manhattan
Middle name: C

Source-specific fields

Base Salary: $199
Leave Status as of June 30: Active
Overtime Hours: 0
Payroll Number: 470
Regular Hours: 2

Deborah Model appears in Hunter College High School payroll as a Substitute Teacher, with $7,524 reported in 2025 — this entry may combine more than one individual of the same name.

Erika Petersen

Substitute Teacher/Hunter College High School

2025 total comp

$5,779

Base pay: $5,779
Overtime: $0
Other pay: $0
Benefits: $0
Total compensation: $5,779
Hire date: 2001-01-02
Pay basis: Hourly
Work city: Manhattan
Middle name: M

Source-specific fields

Base Salary: $199
Leave Status as of June 30: Active
Overtime Hours: 0
Payroll Number: 470
Regular Hours: 29

Erika Petersen works as a Substitute Teacher for Hunter College High School based in Manhattan. Their tenure dates to 2001, about 24 years. Erika earned $5,779 in 2025.

Anne Bartscherer

Substitute Teacher/Hunter College High School

2025 total comp

$5,779

Base pay: $5,779
Overtime: $0
Other pay: $0
Benefits: $0
Total compensation: $5,779
Hire date: 2024-02-09
Pay basis: Hourly
Work city: Manhattan

Source-specific fields

Base Salary: $199
Leave Status as of June 30: Active
Overtime Hours: 0
Payroll Number: 470
Regular Hours: 29

Anne Bartscherer works as a Substitute Teacher for Hunter College High School based in Manhattan. Their tenure dates to 2024, about a year. Anne earned $5,779 in 2025.

Bethel Caram

Substitute Teacher/Hunter College High School

2025 total comp

$5,281

Base pay: $5,281
Overtime: $0
Other pay: $0
Benefits: $0
Total compensation: $5,281
Hire date: 2005-09-14
Pay basis: Hourly
Work city: Manhattan
Middle name: E

Source-specific fields

Base Salary: $199
Leave Status as of June 30: Active
Overtime Hours: 0
Payroll Number: 470
Regular Hours: 26.5

Bethel Caram holds the role of Substitute Teacher at Hunter College High School based in Manhattan. Their tenure dates to 2005, about 20 years. In 2025, their total compensation was $5,281.

Esther Schnitzer

Substitute Teacher/Hunter College High School

2025 total comp

$5,262

Base pay: $5,262
Overtime: $0
Other pay: $0
Benefits: $0
Total compensation: $5,262
Hire date: 2018-03-05
Pay basis: Annual
Work city: Manhattan
Middle name: M

Source-specific fields

Base Salary: $68,652
Leave Status as of June 30: Ceased
Overtime Hours: 0
Payroll Number: 470
Regular Hours: 106.8

Esther Schnitzer is a Substitute Teacher at Hunter College High School based in Manhattan. Hired in 2018, they have about 7 years of service. 2025 total compensation came to $5,262.