Agency file

Police

Source file: Suffolk County, New York — Salaries by Department / ingested Jun 19, 2026

The Police provides law enforcement and public safety — patrol, criminal investigation, and emergency response.

In 2024, this agency had 3,923 employees with median total compensation of $116,975; the highest distinct record was $713,443.

Year: 2024
Total payroll: $561.8M
Employees: 3,923
Median total: $116,975
Highest record: $713,443

What the records show

Compensation analytics

These summaries compare pay within the agency before listing individual records.

Salary distribution

$18$373,776+

Hover a bar for its range; click to filter the list below.

How 2024 total compensation is spread across the 3,923 employees. Each bar is a pay range; taller bars mean more people earn in that range. The amber line marks the median ($116,975) — half earn less, half more. The far-right bar collects the highest earners.

Average pay composition

Base — $88,124 (62%)
Overtime — $19,182 (13%)
Other — $35,899 (25%)
Benefits — $0 (0%)

What an average paycheck here is made of — base salary versus overtime, other pay (bonuses, allowances), and benefits. A large overtime or other-pay share means take-home often exceeds base salary.

Pay percentiles

10th

25th

Median

75th

90th

$15,115

$60,202

$116,975

$231,090

$290,258

The pay ladder for this department. Someone at the 90th percentile earns $290,258 — more than 90% of the department; the 10th percentile earns $15,115. The shaded band is the middle half of employees (25th–75th percentile).

Largest job titles

5002C - Police Officer

1,810 · $129,288

5059C - School Crossing Guard

463 · $20,231

5010C - Detective (Police)

381 · $276,899

5003C - Sergeant (Police)

281 · $235,973

5006C - Police Officer (Spanish Spk)

159 · $101,382

The most common job titles in this department by headcount, with the median total compensation for each. Click a title to see everyone who holds it.

Record list

Employees

Page 31

Ryan Cuddihy

0764C - Office Systems Analyst III/Police

2024 total comp

$100,369

Sub-department: Association of Municipal Employees (AME-White Collar)
Base pay: $98,143
Overtime: $0
Other pay: $2,227
Benefits: $0
Total compensation: $100,369
Hire date: 2005-06-20

Source-specific fields

Fid: 3258
Terminate: 0

Ryan Cuddihy works as a 0764C - Office Systems Analyst III for Police within Association of Municipal Employees (Ame-White Collar). Hired in 2005, they have about 19 years of service. Ryan earned $100,369 in 2024.

Joseph Mcgoorty

5002C - Police Officer/Police

2024 total comp

$100,345

Sub-department: Police Benevolent Association (PBA)
Base pay: $58,566
Overtime: $3,699
Other pay: $38,080
Benefits: $0
Total compensation: $100,345
Hire date: 2021-03-29

Source-specific fields

Fid: 10002
Terminate: 0

Joseph Mcgoorty holds the role of 5002C - Police Officer at Police within Police Benevolent Association (Pba). Their tenure dates to 2021, about 3 years. In 2024, their total compensation was $100,345.

Skylar Harris

5002C - Police Officer/Police

2024 total comp

$100,314

Sub-department: Police Benevolent Association (PBA)
Base pay: $65,995
Overtime: $13,650
Other pay: $20,669
Benefits: $0
Total compensation: $100,314
Hire date: 2022-01-18

Source-specific fields

Fid: 6493
Terminate: 0

Skylar Harris works as a 5002C - Police Officer for Police within Police Benevolent Association (Pba). Hired in 2022, they have about 2 years of service. Skylar earned $100,314 in 2024.

Brian Donofrio

0178C - Public Safety Dispatcher II/Police

2024 total comp

$100,308

Sub-department: Association of Municipal Employees (AME-White Collar)
Base pay: $91,438
Overtime: $0
Other pay: $8,870
Benefits: $0
Total compensation: $100,308
Hire date: 2011-04-11

Source-specific fields

Fid: 4107
Terminate: 0

At Police, Brian Donofrio serves as a 0178C - Public Safety Dispatcher II within Association of Municipal Employees (Ame-White Collar). Hired in 2011, they have about 13 years of service. Their 2024 pay totaled $100,308.

Ryan Defelippis

0981C - Publ Relations Specialist/Police

2024 total comp

$100,197

Sub-department: Association of Municipal Employees (AME-White Collar)
Base pay: $87,072
Overtime: $4,471
Other pay: $8,654
Benefits: $0
Total compensation: $100,197
Hire date: 2007-12-31

Source-specific fields

Fid: 3915
Terminate: 0

Ryan Defelippis is a 0981C - Publ Relations Specialist at Police within Association of Municipal Employees (Ame-White Collar). Their tenure dates to 2007, about 17 years. 2024 total compensation came to $100,197.

Christopher Kelly

7198C - Assistant Fleet Service Manager/Police

2024 total comp

$100,170

Sub-department: Association of Municipal Employees (AME-White Collar)
Base pay: $75,160
Overtime: $22,783
Other pay: $2,227
Benefits: $0
Total compensation: $100,170
Hire date: 2006-07-17

Source-specific fields

Fid: 7626
Terminate: 0

At Police, Christopher Kelly serves as a 7198C - Assistant Fleet Service Manager within Association of Municipal Employees (Ame-White Collar). They have served since 2006 (about 18 years). Their 2024 pay totaled $100,170.

Tyler Luthy

5002C - Police Officer/Police

2024 total comp

$100,168

Sub-department: Police Benevolent Association (PBA)
Base pay: $71,894
Overtime: $5,413
Other pay: $22,861
Benefits: $0
Total compensation: $100,168
Hire date: 2021-04-12

Source-specific fields

Fid: 8928
Terminate: 0

Tyler Luthy is a 5002C - Police Officer at Police within Police Benevolent Association (Pba). Their tenure dates to 2021, about 3 years. 2024 total compensation came to $100,168.

Kevin Hutchinson

5002C - Police Officer/Police

2024 total comp

$100,155

Sub-department: Police Benevolent Association (PBA)
Base pay: $65,805
Overtime: $16,965
Other pay: $17,385
Benefits: $0
Total compensation: $100,155
Hire date: 2022-01-18

Source-specific fields

Fid: 6862
Terminate: 0

Kevin Hutchinson is a 5002C - Police Officer at Police within Police Benevolent Association (Pba). Their tenure dates to 2022, about 2 years. 2024 total compensation came to $100,155.

Kevin Blyman

5002C - Police Officer/Police

2024 total comp

$100,073

Sub-department: Police Benevolent Association (PBA)
Base pay: $67,605
Overtime: $15,159
Other pay: $17,309
Benefits: $0
Total compensation: $100,073
Hire date: 2021-10-25

Source-specific fields

Fid: 1376
Terminate: 0

At Police, Kevin Blyman serves as a 5002C - Police Officer within Police Benevolent Association (Pba). They have served since 2021 (about 3 years). Their 2024 pay totaled $100,073.

Kevin Cavaluzzo

5002C - Police Officer/Police

2024 total comp

$99,997

Sub-department: Police Benevolent Association (PBA)
Base pay: $61,489
Overtime: $14,994
Other pay: $23,514
Benefits: $0
Total compensation: $99,997
Hire date: 2021-10-25

Source-specific fields

Fid: 2669
Terminate: 0

At Police, Kevin Cavaluzzo serves as a 5002C - Police Officer within Police Benevolent Association (Pba). They have served since 2021 (about 3 years). Their 2024 pay totaled $99,997.

Marianne Avanzato

0903C - Administrator I/Police

2024 total comp

$99,986

Sub-department: Association of Municipal Employees (AME-White Collar)
Base pay: $87,072
Overtime: $10,288
Other pay: $2,627
Benefits: $0
Total compensation: $99,986
Hire date: 1999-05-03

Source-specific fields

Fid: 508
Terminate: 0

Marianne Avanzato is a 0903C - Administrator I at Police within Association of Municipal Employees (Ame-White Collar). Hired in 1999, they have about 25 years of service. 2024 total compensation came to $99,986.

Sean Whelan

5002C - Police Officer/Police

2024 total comp

$99,967

Sub-department: Police Benevolent Association (PBA)
Base pay: $62,913
Overtime: $20,094
Other pay: $16,960
Benefits: $0
Total compensation: $99,967
Hire date: 2022-09-12

Source-specific fields

Fid: 16100
Terminate: 0

Sean Whelan is a 5002C - Police Officer at Police within Police Benevolent Association (Pba). They have served since 2022 (about 2 years). 2024 total compensation came to $99,967.

Steven Siegel

5002C - Police Officer/Police

2024 total comp

$99,852

Sub-department: Police Benevolent Association (PBA)
Base pay: $71,641
Overtime: $3,462
Other pay: $24,749
Benefits: $0
Total compensation: $99,852
Hire date: 2021-04-12

Source-specific fields

Fid: 14307
Terminate: 0

At Police, Steven Siegel serves as a 5002C - Police Officer within Police Benevolent Association (Pba). Hired in 2021, they have about 3 years of service. Their 2024 pay totaled $99,852.

Chabely Villalona

5006C - Police Officer (Spanish Spk)/Police

2024 total comp

$99,719

Sub-department: Police Benevolent Association (PBA)
Base pay: $66,732
Overtime: $15,779
Other pay: $17,208
Benefits: $0
Total compensation: $99,719
Hire date: 2021-12-06

Source-specific fields

Fid: 15742
Terminate: 0

At Police, Chabely Villalona serves as a 5006C - Police Officer (Spanish Spk) within Police Benevolent Association (Pba). Hired in 2021, they have about 3 years of service. Their 2024 pay totaled $99,719.

Christina Caldea

0903C - Administrator I/Police

2024 total comp

$99,717

Sub-department: Association of Municipal Employees (AME-White Collar)
Base pay: $85,695
Overtime: $11,396
Other pay: $2,627
Benefits: $0
Total compensation: $99,717
Hire date: 1998-12-21

Source-specific fields

Fid: 2318
Terminate: 0

Christina Caldea works as a 0903C - Administrator I for Police within Association of Municipal Employees (Ame-White Collar). Hired in 1998, they have about 26 years of service. Christina earned $99,717 in 2024.

Alyssa Ortiz

5002C - Police Officer/Police

2024 total comp

$99,527

Sub-department: Police Benevolent Association (PBA)
Base pay: $62,913
Overtime: $19,654
Other pay: $16,960
Benefits: $0
Total compensation: $99,527
Hire date: 2022-09-12

Source-specific fields

Fid: 11295
Terminate: 0

Alyssa Ortiz holds the role of 5002C - Police Officer at Police within Police Benevolent Association (Pba). They have served since 2022 (about 2 years). In 2024, their total compensation was $99,527.

James Faughnan

5002C - Police Officer/Police

2024 total comp

$99,431

Sub-department: Police Benevolent Association (PBA)
Base pay: $71,218
Overtime: $11,038
Other pay: $17,175
Benefits: $0
Total compensation: $99,431
Hire date: 2022-09-12

Source-specific fields

Fid: 5040
Terminate: 0

James Faughnan holds the role of 5002C - Police Officer at Police within Police Benevolent Association (Pba). Their tenure dates to 2022, about 2 years. In 2024, their total compensation was $99,431.

Douglas Gaul

5002C - Police Officer/Police

2024 total comp

$99,302

Sub-department: Police Benevolent Association (PBA)
Base pay: $71,804
Overtime: $9,319
Other pay: $18,180
Benefits: $0
Total compensation: $99,302
Hire date: 2021-04-12

Source-specific fields

Fid: 5344
Terminate: 0

At Police, Douglas Gaul serves as a 5002C - Police Officer within Police Benevolent Association (Pba). Their tenure dates to 2021, about 3 years. Their 2024 pay totaled $99,302.

William Corwin

5002C - Police Officer/Police

2024 total comp

$99,221

Sub-department: Police Benevolent Association (PBA)
Base pay: $72,116
Overtime: $2,575
Other pay: $24,530
Benefits: $0
Total compensation: $99,221
Hire date: 2021-03-29

Source-specific fields

Fid: 2835
Terminate: 0

At Police, William Corwin serves as a 5002C - Police Officer within Police Benevolent Association (Pba). Hired in 2021, they have about 3 years of service. Their 2024 pay totaled $99,221.

Daniel Catini

5002C - Police Officer/Police

2024 total comp

$99,212

Sub-department: Police Benevolent Association (PBA)
Base pay: $62,930
Overtime: $19,322
Other pay: $16,960
Benefits: $0
Total compensation: $99,212
Hire date: 2022-09-12

Source-specific fields

Fid: 2588
Terminate: 0

At Police, Daniel Catini serves as a 5002C - Police Officer within Police Benevolent Association (Pba). They have served since 2022 (about 2 years). Their 2024 pay totaled $99,212.

Christopher Bonenfant

5002C - Police Officer/Police

2024 total comp

$98,921

Sub-department: Police Benevolent Association (PBA)
Base pay: $72,116
Overtime: $2,275
Other pay: $24,530
Benefits: $0
Total compensation: $98,921
Hire date: 2021-03-29

Source-specific fields

Fid: 1594
Terminate: 0

Christopher Bonenfant works as a 5002C - Police Officer for Police within Police Benevolent Association (Pba). They have served since 2021 (about 3 years). Christopher earned $98,921 in 2024.

Diego A Alayogonzalez

5006C - Police Officer (Spanish Spk)/Police

2024 total comp

$98,909

Sub-department: Police Benevolent Association (PBA)
Base pay: $64,929
Overtime: $16,886
Other pay: $17,094
Benefits: $0
Total compensation: $98,909
Hire date: 2021-12-06

Source-specific fields

Fid: 223
Terminate: 0

At Police, Diego A Alayogonzalez serves as a 5006C - Police Officer (Spanish Spk) within Police Benevolent Association (Pba). They have served since 2021 (about 3 years). Their 2024 pay totaled $98,909.

Michele Smalley

0903C - Administrator I/Police

2024 total comp

$98,831

Sub-department: Association of Municipal Employees (AME-White Collar)
Base pay: $83,113
Overtime: $13,242
Other pay: $2,477
Benefits: $0
Total compensation: $98,831
Hire date: 2001-06-25

Source-specific fields

Fid: 14442
Terminate: 0

At Police, Michele Smalley serves as a 0903C - Administrator I within Association of Municipal Employees (Ame-White Collar). They have served since 2001 (about 23 years). Their 2024 pay totaled $98,831.

Paige Alonge

5002C - Police Officer/Police

2024 total comp

$98,734

Sub-department: Police Benevolent Association (PBA)
Base pay: $67,605
Overtime: $13,820
Other pay: $17,309
Benefits: $0
Total compensation: $98,734
Hire date: 2021-10-25

Source-specific fields

Fid: 272
Terminate: 0

Paige Alonge holds the role of 5002C - Police Officer at Police within Police Benevolent Association (Pba). They have served since 2021 (about 3 years). In 2024, their total compensation was $98,734.

Peter Noonan

5002C - Police Officer/Police

2024 total comp

$98,694

Sub-department: Police Benevolent Association (PBA)
Base pay: $66,002
Overtime: $10,946
Other pay: $21,745
Benefits: $0
Total compensation: $98,694
Hire date: 2022-01-18

Source-specific fields

Fid: 10903
Terminate: 0

At Police, Peter Noonan serves as a 5002C - Police Officer within Police Benevolent Association (Pba). Hired in 2022, they have about 2 years of service. Their 2024 pay totaled $98,694.

Michael Robbins

5002C - Police Officer/Police

2024 total comp

$98,649

Sub-department: Police Benevolent Association (PBA)
Base pay: $69,745
Overtime: $5,831
Other pay: $23,073
Benefits: $0
Total compensation: $98,649
Hire date: 2021-12-06

Source-specific fields

Fid: 13000
Terminate: 0

At Police, Michael Robbins serves as a 5002C - Police Officer within Police Benevolent Association (Pba). Their tenure dates to 2021, about 3 years. Their 2024 pay totaled $98,649.

Lauren Handy

5002C - Police Officer/Police

2024 total comp

$98,586

Sub-department: Police Benevolent Association (PBA)
Base pay: $72,094
Overtime: $8,982
Other pay: $17,510
Benefits: $0
Total compensation: $98,586
Hire date: 2021-03-29

Source-specific fields

Fid: 6445
Terminate: 0

Lauren Handy is a 5002C - Police Officer at Police within Police Benevolent Association (Pba). Hired in 2021, they have about 3 years of service. 2024 total compensation came to $98,586.

Anthony Fusco

5002C - Police Officer/Police

2024 total comp

$98,571

Sub-department: Police Benevolent Association (PBA)
Base pay: $71,003
Overtime: $7,938
Other pay: $19,631
Benefits: $0
Total compensation: $98,571
Hire date: 2021-04-12

Source-specific fields

Fid: 5460
Terminate: 0

Anthony Fusco works as a 5002C - Police Officer for Police within Police Benevolent Association (Pba). They have served since 2021 (about 3 years). Anthony earned $98,571 in 2024.

Kathryn Mcdonald

0222C - Senior Accountant/Police

2024 total comp

$98,559

Sub-department: Association of Municipal Employees (AME-White Collar)
Base pay: $96,583
Overtime: $0
Other pay: $1,977
Benefits: $0
Total compensation: $98,559
Hire date: 2009-12-14

Source-specific fields

Fid: 9654
Terminate: 0

Kathryn Mcdonald is a 0222C - Senior Accountant at Police within Association of Municipal Employees (Ame-White Collar). Hired in 2009, they have about 15 years of service. 2024 total compensation came to $98,559.

Alexander Scammon

5002C - Police Officer/Police

2024 total comp

$98,541

Sub-department: Police Benevolent Association (PBA)
Base pay: $71,783
Overtime: $2,261
Other pay: $24,497
Benefits: $0
Total compensation: $98,541
Hire date: 2021-04-12

Source-specific fields

Fid: 13763
Terminate: 0

Alexander Scammon holds the role of 5002C - Police Officer at Police within Police Benevolent Association (Pba). They have served since 2021 (about 3 years). In 2024, their total compensation was $98,541.

Christopher Sygney

5002C - Police Officer/Police

2024 total comp

$98,438

Sub-department: Police Benevolent Association (PBA)
Base pay: $72,123
Overtime: $8,805
Other pay: $17,510
Benefits: $0
Total compensation: $98,438
Hire date: 2016-12-26

Source-specific fields

Fid: 15050
Terminate: 0

Christopher Sygney works as a 5002C - Police Officer for Police within Police Benevolent Association (Pba). They have served since 2016 (about 8 years). Christopher earned $98,438 in 2024.

Kyle Simpson

5002C - Police Officer/Police

2024 total comp

$98,414

Sub-department: Police Benevolent Association (PBA)
Base pay: $71,783
Overtime: $2,134
Other pay: $24,497
Benefits: $0
Total compensation: $98,414
Hire date: 2021-04-12

Source-specific fields

Fid: 14150
Terminate: 0

Kyle Simpson works as a 5002C - Police Officer for Police within Police Benevolent Association (Pba). Hired in 2021, they have about 3 years of service. Kyle earned $98,414 in 2024.

Stephen Silva

5002C - Police Officer/Police

2024 total comp

$98,382

Sub-department: Police Benevolent Association (PBA)
Base pay: $62,913
Overtime: $18,122
Other pay: $17,347
Benefits: $0
Total compensation: $98,382
Hire date: 2022-09-12

Source-specific fields

Fid: 14185
Terminate: 0

At Police, Stephen Silva serves as a 5002C - Police Officer within Police Benevolent Association (Pba). Their tenure dates to 2022, about 2 years. Their 2024 pay totaled $98,382.

John Pusateri

5002C - Police Officer/Police

2024 total comp

$98,382

Sub-department: Police Benevolent Association (PBA)
Base pay: $66,421
Overtime: $2,102
Other pay: $29,859
Benefits: $0
Total compensation: $98,382
Hire date: 2021-04-12

Source-specific fields

Fid: 12251
Terminate: 0

At Police, John Pusateri serves as a 5002C - Police Officer within Police Benevolent Association (Pba). Their tenure dates to 2021, about 3 years. Their 2024 pay totaled $98,382.

Douglas Minogue

5002C - Police Officer/Police

2024 total comp

$98,312

Sub-department: Police Benevolent Association (PBA)
Base pay: $60,803
Overtime: $20,741
Other pay: $16,768
Benefits: $0
Total compensation: $98,312
Hire date: 2023-01-17

Source-specific fields

Fid: 10621
Terminate: 0

Douglas Minogue is a 5002C - Police Officer at Police within Police Benevolent Association (Pba). They have served since 2023 (about a year). 2024 total compensation came to $98,312.

Michael Guarino

5002C - Police Officer/Police

2024 total comp

$98,076

Sub-department: Police Benevolent Association (PBA)
Base pay: $72,116
Overtime: $1,429
Other pay: $24,530
Benefits: $0
Total compensation: $98,076
Hire date: 2021-03-29

Source-specific fields

Fid: 6249
Terminate: 0

At Police, Michael Guarino serves as a 5002C - Police Officer within Police Benevolent Association (Pba). Hired in 2021, they have about 3 years of service. Their 2024 pay totaled $98,076.

Jessica Carere

5002C - Police Officer/Police

2024 total comp

$98,074

Sub-department: Police Benevolent Association (PBA)
Base pay: $55,651
Overtime: $18,228
Other pay: $24,196
Benefits: $0
Total compensation: $98,074
Hire date: 2022-09-12

Source-specific fields

Fid: 2125
Terminate: 0

Jessica Carere holds the role of 5002C - Police Officer at Police within Police Benevolent Association (Pba). Their tenure dates to 2022, about 2 years. In 2024, their total compensation was $98,074.

Michael Myers

5002C - Police Officer/Police

2024 total comp

$97,976

Sub-department: Police Benevolent Association (PBA)
Base pay: $60,840
Overtime: $20,368
Other pay: $16,768
Benefits: $0
Total compensation: $97,976
Hire date: 2023-01-17

Source-specific fields

Fid: 10888
Terminate: 0

At Police, Michael Myers serves as a 5002C - Police Officer within Police Benevolent Association (Pba). They have served since 2023 (about a year). Their 2024 pay totaled $97,976.

Joshua Valderrama

5006C - Police Officer (Spanish Spk)/Police

2024 total comp

$97,838

Sub-department: Police Benevolent Association (PBA)
Base pay: $62,913
Overtime: $17,965
Other pay: $16,960
Benefits: $0
Total compensation: $97,838
Hire date: 2022-09-12

Source-specific fields

Fid: 15674
Terminate: 0

Joshua Valderrama holds the role of 5006C - Police Officer (Spanish Spk) at Police within Police Benevolent Association (Pba). They have served since 2022 (about 2 years). In 2024, their total compensation was $97,838.

Daniel Pellegrino

5002C - Police Officer/Police

2024 total comp

$97,817

Sub-department: Police Benevolent Association (PBA)
Base pay: $66,739
Overtime: $11,780
Other pay: $19,298
Benefits: $0
Total compensation: $97,817
Hire date: 2021-12-06

Source-specific fields

Fid: 11860
Terminate: 0

Daniel Pellegrino is a 5002C - Police Officer at Police within Police Benevolent Association (Pba). They have served since 2021 (about 3 years). 2024 total compensation came to $97,817.