Suffolk County, New York / Sheriff
Agency file
The Sheriff provides law enforcement and public safety — patrol, criminal investigation, and emergency response.
In 2024, this agency had 1,379 employees with median total compensation of $129,826; the highest distinct record was $428,467.
What the records show
These summaries compare pay within the agency before listing individual records.
How 2024 total compensation is spread across the 1,379 employees. Each bar is a pay range; taller bars mean more people earn in that range. The amber line marks the median ($129,826) — half earn less, half more. The far-right bar collects the highest earners.
What an average paycheck here is made of — base salary versus overtime, other pay (bonuses, allowances), and benefits. A large overtime or other-pay share means take-home often exceeds base salary.
The pay ladder for this department. Someone at the 90th percentile earns $229,523 — more than 90% of the department; the 10th percentile earns $38,492. The shaded band is the middle half of employees (25th–75th percentile).
The most common job titles in this department by headcount, with the median total compensation for each. Click a title to see everyone who holds it.
Record list
Highest-paid first / page 17
5531C - Deputy Sheriff I/Sheriff
Source-specific fields
Alexandra Guerrero-Macchia is a 5531C - Deputy Sheriff I at Sheriff within Deputy Sheriffs Pba (Dspba). They have served since 2014 (about 10 years). 2024 total compensation came to $140,619.
5531C - Deputy Sheriff I/Sheriff
Source-specific fields
At Sheriff, Jennifer Valentine serves as a 5531C - Deputy Sheriff I within Deputy Sheriffs Pba (Dspba). Their tenure dates to 2007, about 17 years. Their 2024 pay totaled $140,584.
5501C - Correction Officer I/Sheriff
Source-specific fields
Alex Porcillo is a 5501C - Correction Officer I at Sheriff within Correction Officers Association (Coa). They have served since 2018 (about 6 years). 2024 total compensation came to $140,133.
5501C - Correction Officer I/Sheriff
Source-specific fields
Charles Brindle works as a 5501C - Correction Officer I for Sheriff within Correction Officers Association (Coa). Their tenure dates to 2015, about 9 years. Charles earned $139,917 in 2024.
5501C - Correction Officer I/Sheriff
Source-specific fields
At Sheriff, John Conway serves as a 5501C - Correction Officer I within Correction Officers Association (Coa). They have served since 2010 (about 14 years). Their 2024 pay totaled $139,495.
5531C - Deputy Sheriff I/Sheriff
Source-specific fields
Danielle Milidantri works as a 5531C - Deputy Sheriff I for Sheriff within Deputy Sheriffs Pba (Dspba). Their tenure dates to 2010, about 14 years. Danielle earned $139,481 in 2024.
5501C - Correction Officer I/Sheriff
Source-specific fields
Casey Callagy holds the role of 5501C - Correction Officer I at Sheriff within Correction Officers Association (Coa). Their tenure dates to 2013, about 11 years. In 2024, their total compensation was $139,289.
5511C - Correction Officer I (Invest)/Sheriff
Source-specific fields
Nancy Tyson works as a 5511C - Correction Officer I (Invest) for Sheriff within Correction Officers Association (Coa). Hired in 2010, they have about 14 years of service. Nancy earned $139,072 in 2024.
5501C - Correction Officer I/Sheriff
Source-specific fields
Isabel Shadell works as a 5501C - Correction Officer I for Sheriff within Correction Officers Association (Coa). Their tenure dates to 2018, about 6 years. Isabel earned $138,848 in 2024.
5535C - Deputy Sheriff I (Invest)/Sheriff
Source-specific fields
Vincent Giordano is a 5535C - Deputy Sheriff I (Invest) at Sheriff within Deputy Sheriffs Pba (Dspba). Hired in 2011, they have about 13 years of service. 2024 total compensation came to $138,797.
5502C - Correction Officer II/Sheriff
Source-specific fields
At Sheriff, Nicholas Russo serves as a 5502C - Correction Officer II within Correction Officers Association (Coa). They have served since 2010 (about 14 years). Their 2024 pay totaled $138,705.
5501C - Correction Officer I/Sheriff
Source-specific fields
Peter Lambert is a 5501C - Correction Officer I at Sheriff within Correction Officers Association (Coa). They have served since 2008 (about 16 years). 2024 total compensation came to $137,967.
5535C - Deputy Sheriff I (Invest)/Sheriff
Source-specific fields
Frank Lapocca is a 5535C - Deputy Sheriff I (Invest) at Sheriff within Deputy Sheriffs Pba (Dspba). They have served since 2015 (about 9 years). 2024 total compensation came to $137,605.
5535C - Deputy Sheriff I (Invest)/Sheriff
Source-specific fields
At Sheriff, Dustin Defilippo serves as a 5535C - Deputy Sheriff I (Invest) within Deputy Sheriffs Pba (Dspba). Their tenure dates to 2019, about 5 years. Their 2024 pay totaled $137,285.
8177C - Assistant Jail Head Cook/Sheriff
Source-specific fields
At Sheriff, Richard Miller serves as a 8177C - Assistant Jail Head Cook within Association of Municipal Employees (Ame-Blue Collar). Their tenure dates to 2002, about 22 years. Their 2024 pay totaled $137,283.
5702C - Senior Criminal Ident Technician/Sheriff
Source-specific fields
James Fischetti holds the role of 5702C - Senior Criminal Ident Technician at Sheriff within Association of Municipal Employees (Ame-White Collar). Hired in 1997, they have about 27 years of service. In 2024, their total compensation was $137,018.
0565C - Systems Analyst Supvr(C-J)/Sheriff
Source-specific fields
At Sheriff, Jerome Pizzuto serves as a 0565C - Systems Analyst Supvr(C-J) within Association of Municipal Employees (Ame-White Collar). Their tenure dates to 1992, about 32 years. Their 2024 pay totaled $136,923.
9404C - Undersheriff/Sheriff
Source-specific fields
Michael Catuosco holds the role of 9404C - Undersheriff at Sheriff within Management. Hired in 2018, they have about 6 years of service. In 2024, their total compensation was $136,708.
5501C - Correction Officer I/Sheriff
Source-specific fields
Richard Yip holds the role of 5501C - Correction Officer I at Sheriff within Correction Officers Association (Coa). Hired in 2008, they have about 16 years of service. In 2024, their total compensation was $136,509.
5531C - Deputy Sheriff I/Sheriff
Source-specific fields
James Milano works as a 5531C - Deputy Sheriff I for Sheriff within Deputy Sheriffs Pba (Dspba). Hired in 2023, they have about a year of service. James earned $136,178 in 2024.
5501C - Correction Officer I/Sheriff
Source-specific fields
Kevin Reynolds is a 5501C - Correction Officer I at Sheriff within Correction Officers Association (Coa). Their tenure dates to 2015, about 9 years. 2024 total compensation came to $135,850.
5511C - Correction Officer I (Invest)/Sheriff
Source-specific fields
Christopher Stewart is a 5511C - Correction Officer I (Invest) at Sheriff within Correction Officers Association (Coa). They have served since 2013 (about 11 years). 2024 total compensation came to $135,674.
5501C - Correction Officer I/Sheriff
Source-specific fields
At Sheriff, Colleen Weinfeld serves as a 5501C - Correction Officer I within Correction Officers Association (Coa). Their tenure dates to 1999, about 25 years. Their 2024 pay totaled $135,120.
5501C - Correction Officer I/Sheriff
Source-specific fields
Zachary Salazar works as a 5501C - Correction Officer I for Sheriff within Correction Officers Association (Coa). Their tenure dates to 2017, about 7 years. Zachary earned $134,621 in 2024.
5501C - Correction Officer I/Sheriff
Source-specific fields
At Sheriff, Stephanie Fazio serves as a 5501C - Correction Officer I within Correction Officers Association (Coa). Their tenure dates to 2014, about 10 years. Their 2024 pay totaled $134,317.
5531C - Deputy Sheriff I/Sheriff
Source-specific fields
Crystie Rios works as a 5531C - Deputy Sheriff I for Sheriff within Deputy Sheriffs Pba (Dspba). They have served since 2016 (about 8 years). Crystie earned $134,154 in 2024.
5501C - Correction Officer I/Sheriff
Source-specific fields
Thomas Celentano works as a 5501C - Correction Officer I for Sheriff within Correction Officers Association (Coa). Hired in 2015, they have about 9 years of service. Thomas earned $133,986 in 2024.
5501C - Correction Officer I/Sheriff
Source-specific fields
Anthony Fiorante holds the role of 5501C - Correction Officer I at Sheriff within Correction Officers Association (Coa). They have served since 2019 (about 5 years). In 2024, their total compensation was $133,897.
5501C - Correction Officer I/Sheriff
Source-specific fields
Casey Pearson is a 5501C - Correction Officer I at Sheriff within Correction Officers Association (Coa). They have served since 2013 (about 11 years). 2024 total compensation came to $133,891.
5531C - Deputy Sheriff I/Sheriff
Source-specific fields
At Sheriff, Kathleen Benasutti serves as a 5531C - Deputy Sheriff I within Deputy Sheriffs Pba (Dspba). Their tenure dates to 2006, about 18 years. Their 2024 pay totaled $133,155.
5501C - Correction Officer I/Sheriff
Source-specific fields
Jason Conforti holds the role of 5501C - Correction Officer I at Sheriff within Correction Officers Association (Coa). Hired in 2004, they have about 20 years of service. In 2024, their total compensation was $133,074.
5501C - Correction Officer I/Sheriff
Source-specific fields
Matthew Manthe works as a 5501C - Correction Officer I for Sheriff within Correction Officers Association (Coa). They have served since 2011 (about 13 years). Matthew earned $133,066 in 2024.
5511C - Correction Officer I (Invest)/Sheriff
Source-specific fields
At Sheriff, Lorissa Agate serves as a 5511C - Correction Officer I (Invest) within Correction Officers Association (Coa). Their tenure dates to 2011, about 13 years. Their 2024 pay totaled $132,751.
5501C - Correction Officer I/Sheriff
Source-specific fields
Maryann Mendola holds the role of 5501C - Correction Officer I at Sheriff within Correction Officers Association (Coa). They have served since 2015 (about 9 years). In 2024, their total compensation was $132,702.
5501C - Correction Officer I/Sheriff
Source-specific fields
Christopher Pierre holds the role of 5501C - Correction Officer I at Sheriff within Correction Officers Association (Coa). They have served since 1994 (about 30 years). In 2024, their total compensation was $132,664.
5501C - Correction Officer I/Sheriff
Source-specific fields
Douglas Parsloe works as a 5501C - Correction Officer I for Sheriff within Correction Officers Association (Coa). Hired in 2015, they have about 9 years of service. Douglas earned $132,552 in 2024.
5501C - Correction Officer I/Sheriff
Source-specific fields
Susan Agate holds the role of 5501C - Correction Officer I at Sheriff within Correction Officers Association (Coa). They have served since 2004 (about 20 years). In 2024, their total compensation was $132,450.
5501C - Correction Officer I/Sheriff
Source-specific fields
Steven Figari is a 5501C - Correction Officer I at Sheriff within Correction Officers Association (Coa). They have served since 2015 (about 9 years). 2024 total compensation came to $132,427.
5501C - Correction Officer I/Sheriff
Source-specific fields
Gina Ropell works as a 5501C - Correction Officer I for Sheriff within Correction Officers Association (Coa). They have served since 2008 (about 16 years). Gina earned $132,425 in 2024.
5501C - Correction Officer I/Sheriff
Source-specific fields
Anthony Grippaldi is a 5501C - Correction Officer I at Sheriff within Correction Officers Association (Coa). They have served since 2011 (about 13 years). 2024 total compensation came to $132,217.