GCGovComp.app

Suffolk County, New York / Sheriff

Agency file

Sheriff

Source file: Suffolk County, New York — Salaries by Department / ingested Jun 19, 2026

The Sheriff provides law enforcement and public safety — patrol, criminal investigation, and emergency response.

In 2024, this agency had 1,379 employees with median total compensation of $129,826; the highest distinct record was $428,467.

Year
2024
Employees
1,379
Median total
$129,826
Highest record
$428,467

What the records show

Compensation analytics

These summaries compare pay within the agency before listing individual records.

Salary distribution

$15$282,573+

How 2024 total compensation is spread across the 1,379 employees. Each bar is a pay range; taller bars mean more people earn in that range. The amber line marks the median ($129,826) — half earn less, half more. The far-right bar collects the highest earners.

Average pay composition

  • Base$83,542 (62%)
  • Overtime$36,660 (27%)
  • Other$14,108 (11%)
  • Benefits$0 (0%)

What an average paycheck here is made of — base salary versus overtime, other pay (bonuses, allowances), and benefits. A large overtime or other-pay share means take-home often exceeds base salary.

Pay percentiles

10th
25th
Median
75th
90th
$38,492
$78,032
$129,826
$189,899
$229,523

The pay ladder for this department. Someone at the 90th percentile earns $229,523 — more than 90% of the department; the 10th percentile earns $38,492. The shaded band is the middle half of employees (25th–75th percentile).

Largest job titles

The most common job titles in this department by headcount, with the median total compensation for each. Click a title to see everyone who holds it.

Record list

Employees

Highest-paid first / page 20

Ann Marie Bennett

0903C - Administrator I/Sheriff

2024 total comp
$116,382
Sub-department
Association of Municipal Employees (AME-White Collar)
Base pay
$87,072
Overtime
$26,683
Other pay
$2,627
Benefits
$0
Total compensation
$116,382
Hire date
1995-06-19

Source-specific fields

Fid
933
Terminate
0

Ann Marie Bennett works as a 0903C - Administrator I for Sheriff within Association of Municipal Employees (Ame-White Collar). Hired in 1995, they have about 29 years of service. Ann earned $116,382 in 2024.

Keenen Chisholm

5501C - Correction Officer I/Sheriff

2024 total comp
$116,109
Sub-department
Correction Officers Association (COA)
Base pay
$75,207
Overtime
$31,461
Other pay
$9,442
Benefits
$0
Total compensation
$116,109
Hire date
2018-05-14

Source-specific fields

Fid
2793
Terminate
0

At Sheriff, Keenen Chisholm serves as a 5501C - Correction Officer I within Correction Officers Association (Coa). Their tenure dates to 2018, about 6 years. Their 2024 pay totaled $116,109.

Michael Ryan

5501C - Correction Officer I/Sheriff

2024 total comp
$115,880
Sub-department
Correction Officers Association (COA)
Base pay
$77,422
Overtime
$30,226
Other pay
$8,232
Benefits
$0
Total compensation
$115,880
Hire date
2017-09-25

Source-specific fields

Fid
13357
Terminate
0

Michael Ryan works as a 5501C - Correction Officer I for Sheriff within Correction Officers Association (Coa). Hired in 2017, they have about 7 years of service. Michael earned $115,880 in 2024.

Jeanine Young

5501C - Correction Officer I/Sheriff

2024 total comp
$115,597
Sub-department
Correction Officers Association (COA)
Base pay
$69,554
Overtime
$38,429
Other pay
$7,614
Benefits
$0
Total compensation
$115,597
Hire date
2013-04-29

Source-specific fields

Fid
16489
Terminate
0

At Sheriff, Jeanine Young serves as a 5501C - Correction Officer I within Correction Officers Association (Coa). Hired in 2013, they have about 11 years of service. Their 2024 pay totaled $115,597.

Johnathan Stein

5501C - Correction Officer I/Sheriff

2024 total comp
$115,149
Sub-department
Correction Officers Association (COA)
Base pay
$54,589
Overtime
$482
Other pay
$60,078
Benefits
$0
Total compensation
$115,149
Hire date
2011-10-31

Source-specific fields

Fid
14710
Terminate
0

At Sheriff, Johnathan Stein serves as a 5501C - Correction Officer I within Correction Officers Association (Coa). Hired in 2011, they have about 13 years of service. Their 2024 pay totaled $115,149.

Thomas Lombardi

5501C - Correction Officer I/Sheriff

2024 total comp
$114,926
Sub-department
Correction Officers Association (COA)
Base pay
$90,369
Overtime
$15,360
Other pay
$9,197
Benefits
$0
Total compensation
$114,926
Hire date
2015-08-03

Source-specific fields

Fid
9055
Terminate
0

Thomas Lombardi holds the role of 5501C - Correction Officer I at Sheriff within Correction Officers Association (Coa). Their tenure dates to 2015, about 9 years. In 2024, their total compensation was $114,926.

Henry Marquez

5531C - Deputy Sheriff I/Sheriff

2024 total comp
$114,528
Sub-department
Deputy Sheriffs PBA (DSPBA)
Base pay
$71,057
Overtime
$35,264
Other pay
$8,207
Benefits
$0
Total compensation
$114,528
Hire date
2016-12-26

Source-specific fields

Fid
9367
Terminate
0

Henry Marquez is a 5531C - Deputy Sheriff I at Sheriff within Deputy Sheriffs Pba (Dspba). Hired in 2016, they have about 8 years of service. 2024 total compensation came to $114,528.

Jayne Haberland

0207C - Principal Account Clerk/Sheriff

2024 total comp
$114,506
Sub-department
Association of Municipal Employees (AME-White Collar)
Base pay
$72,493
Overtime
$39,387
Other pay
$2,627
Benefits
$0
Total compensation
$114,506
Hire date
1999-12-20

Source-specific fields

Fid
6363
Terminate
0

Jayne Haberland holds the role of 0207C - Principal Account Clerk at Sheriff within Association of Municipal Employees (Ame-White Collar). Hired in 1999, they have about 25 years of service. In 2024, their total compensation was $114,506.

Sean Ullrich

5501C - Correction Officer I/Sheriff

2024 total comp
$114,505
Sub-department
Correction Officers Association (COA)
Base pay
$76,722
Overtime
$29,678
Other pay
$8,105
Benefits
$0
Total compensation
$114,505
Hire date
2017-09-25

Source-specific fields

Fid
15968
Terminate
0

Sean Ullrich is a 5501C - Correction Officer I at Sheriff within Correction Officers Association (Coa). They have served since 2017 (about 7 years). 2024 total compensation came to $114,505.

David Pascarella

5501C - Correction Officer I/Sheriff

2024 total comp
$114,412
Sub-department
Correction Officers Association (COA)
Base pay
$71,116
Overtime
$34,152
Other pay
$9,143
Benefits
$0
Total compensation
$114,412
Hire date
2011-10-15

Source-specific fields

Fid
11687
Terminate
0

David Pascarella is a 5501C - Correction Officer I at Sheriff within Correction Officers Association (Coa). Their tenure dates to 2011, about 13 years. 2024 total compensation came to $114,412.

Brian Leonard

5501C - Correction Officer I/Sheriff

2024 total comp
$114,397
Sub-department
Correction Officers Association (COA)
Base pay
$69,554
Overtime
$37,229
Other pay
$7,614
Benefits
$0
Total compensation
$114,397
Hire date
2019-01-14

Source-specific fields

Fid
8745
Terminate
0

Brian Leonard works as a 5501C - Correction Officer I for Sheriff within Correction Officers Association (Coa). Their tenure dates to 2019, about 5 years. Brian earned $114,397 in 2024.

Philip Stolze

5501C - Correction Officer I/Sheriff

2024 total comp
$114,338
Sub-department
Correction Officers Association (COA)
Base pay
$77,422
Overtime
$28,684
Other pay
$8,232
Benefits
$0
Total compensation
$114,338
Hire date
2017-09-25

Source-specific fields

Fid
15024
Terminate
0

Philip Stolze holds the role of 5501C - Correction Officer I at Sheriff within Correction Officers Association (Coa). They have served since 2017 (about 7 years). In 2024, their total compensation was $114,338.

Valarie Fitzgibbon

5501C - Correction Officer I/Sheriff

2024 total comp
$114,241
Sub-department
Correction Officers Association (COA)
Base pay
$63,135
Overtime
$28,563
Other pay
$22,544
Benefits
$0
Total compensation
$114,241
Hire date
2017-09-25

Source-specific fields

Fid
4816
Terminate
0

Valarie Fitzgibbon works as a 5501C - Correction Officer I for Sheriff within Correction Officers Association (Coa). They have served since 2017 (about 7 years). Valarie earned $114,241 in 2024.

Cynthia Musumeci

0177C - Public Safety Dispatcher I/Sheriff

2024 total comp
$113,947
Sub-department
Association of Municipal Employees (AME-White Collar)
Base pay
$88,156
Overtime
$17,516
Other pay
$8,275
Benefits
$0
Total compensation
$113,947
Hire date
2011-10-31

Source-specific fields

Fid
11194
Terminate
0

Cynthia Musumeci is a 0177C - Public Safety Dispatcher I at Sheriff within Association of Municipal Employees (Ame-White Collar). They have served since 2011 (about 13 years). 2024 total compensation came to $113,947.

Tina Buenaventura

5501C - Correction Officer I/Sheriff

2024 total comp
$113,815
Sub-department
Correction Officers Association (COA)
Base pay
$69,590
Overtime
$32,626
Other pay
$11,599
Benefits
$0
Total compensation
$113,815
Hire date
2019-01-14

Source-specific fields

Fid
1898
Terminate
0

Tina Buenaventura works as a 5501C - Correction Officer I for Sheriff within Correction Officers Association (Coa). Hired in 2019, they have about 5 years of service. Tina earned $113,815 in 2024.

Patrick Staib

5501C - Correction Officer I/Sheriff

2024 total comp
$113,301
Sub-department
Correction Officers Association (COA)
Base pay
$59,000
Overtime
$26,622
Other pay
$27,679
Benefits
$0
Total compensation
$113,301
Hire date
2017-09-25

Source-specific fields

Fid
14636
Terminate
0

At Sheriff, Patrick Staib serves as a 5501C - Correction Officer I within Correction Officers Association (Coa). They have served since 2017 (about 7 years). Their 2024 pay totaled $113,301.

Kasey Wallace

5531C - Deputy Sheriff I/Sheriff

2024 total comp
$113,275
Sub-department
Deputy Sheriffs PBA (DSPBA)
Base pay
$56,534
Overtime
$50,316
Other pay
$6,424
Benefits
$0
Total compensation
$113,275
Hire date
2021-12-06

Source-specific fields

Fid
16200
Terminate
0

Kasey Wallace works as a 5531C - Deputy Sheriff I for Sheriff within Deputy Sheriffs Pba (Dspba). Hired in 2021, they have about 3 years of service. Kasey earned $113,275 in 2024.

Erik Grady

5501C - Correction Officer I/Sheriff

2024 total comp
$113,185
Sub-department
Correction Officers Association (COA)
Base pay
$77,422
Overtime
$27,531
Other pay
$8,232
Benefits
$0
Total compensation
$113,185
Hire date
2017-09-25

Source-specific fields

Fid
5996
Terminate
0

Erik Grady is a 5501C - Correction Officer I at Sheriff within Correction Officers Association (Coa). Hired in 2017, they have about 7 years of service. 2024 total compensation came to $113,185.

Thomas Mcninney

5531C - Deputy Sheriff I/Sheriff

2024 total comp
$112,483
Sub-department
Deputy Sheriffs PBA (DSPBA)
Base pay
$71,978
Overtime
$33,953
Other pay
$6,552
Benefits
$0
Total compensation
$112,483
Hire date
2017-09-25

Source-specific fields

Fid
10058
Terminate
0

Thomas Mcninney works as a 5531C - Deputy Sheriff I for Sheriff within Deputy Sheriffs Pba (Dspba). Hired in 2017, they have about 7 years of service. Thomas earned $112,483 in 2024.

Joshua Kasin

5501C - Correction Officer I/Sheriff

2024 total comp
$112,208
Sub-department
Correction Officers Association (COA)
Base pay
$71,129
Overtime
$32,347
Other pay
$8,731
Benefits
$0
Total compensation
$112,208
Hire date
2019-01-14

Source-specific fields

Fid
7970
Terminate
0

Joshua Kasin holds the role of 5501C - Correction Officer I at Sheriff within Correction Officers Association (Coa). They have served since 2019 (about 5 years). In 2024, their total compensation was $112,208.

Justin Ladick

5501C - Correction Officer I/Sheriff

2024 total comp
$111,433
Sub-department
Correction Officers Association (COA)
Base pay
$73,532
Overtime
$18,943
Other pay
$18,958
Benefits
$0
Total compensation
$111,433
Hire date
2016-12-26

Source-specific fields

Fid
8088
Terminate
0

Justin Ladick works as a 5501C - Correction Officer I for Sheriff within Correction Officers Association (Coa). Hired in 2016, they have about 8 years of service. Justin earned $111,433 in 2024.

Josef Gratzer

5501C - Correction Officer I/Sheriff

2024 total comp
$111,325
Sub-department
Correction Officers Association (COA)
Base pay
$58,759
Overtime
$43,859
Other pay
$8,707
Benefits
$0
Total compensation
$111,325
Hire date
2021-10-25

Source-specific fields

Fid
6362
Terminate
0

At Sheriff, Josef Gratzer serves as a 5501C - Correction Officer I within Correction Officers Association (Coa). Their tenure dates to 2021, about 3 years. Their 2024 pay totaled $111,325.

Patrick Teich

5531C - Deputy Sheriff I/Sheriff

2024 total comp
$111,043
Sub-department
Deputy Sheriffs PBA (DSPBA)
Base pay
$65,591
Overtime
$37,684
Other pay
$7,768
Benefits
$0
Total compensation
$111,043
Hire date
2019-09-09

Source-specific fields

Fid
15194
Terminate
0

Patrick Teich works as a 5531C - Deputy Sheriff I for Sheriff within Deputy Sheriffs Pba (Dspba). Hired in 2019, they have about 5 years of service. Patrick earned $111,043 in 2024.

Daniel Hahn

5531C - Deputy Sheriff I/Sheriff

2024 total comp
$110,697
Sub-department
Deputy Sheriffs PBA (DSPBA)
Base pay
$66,206
Overtime
$39,197
Other pay
$5,294
Benefits
$0
Total compensation
$110,697
Hire date
2016-12-26

Source-specific fields

Fid
6053
Terminate
0

Daniel Hahn holds the role of 5531C - Deputy Sheriff I at Sheriff within Deputy Sheriffs Pba (Dspba). Hired in 2016, they have about 8 years of service. In 2024, their total compensation was $110,697.

Jeffrey Horne

5501C - Correction Officer I/Sheriff

2024 total comp
$110,671
Sub-department
Correction Officers Association (COA)
Base pay
$61,739
Overtime
$40,441
Other pay
$8,490
Benefits
$0
Total compensation
$110,671
Hire date
2021-05-03

Source-specific fields

Fid
6941
Terminate
0

Jeffrey Horne holds the role of 5501C - Correction Officer I at Sheriff within Correction Officers Association (Coa). Their tenure dates to 2021, about 3 years. In 2024, their total compensation was $110,671.

Thomas Bellucci

5531C - Deputy Sheriff I/Sheriff

2024 total comp
$110,571
Sub-department
Deputy Sheriffs PBA (DSPBA)
Base pay
$65,584
Overtime
$38,032
Other pay
$6,955
Benefits
$0
Total compensation
$110,571
Hire date
2016-12-26

Source-specific fields

Fid
1096
Terminate
0

Thomas Bellucci holds the role of 5531C - Deputy Sheriff I at Sheriff within Deputy Sheriffs Pba (Dspba). Their tenure dates to 2016, about 8 years. In 2024, their total compensation was $110,571.

Maria Barber

0206C - Senior Account Clerk/Sheriff

2024 total comp
$110,437
Sub-department
Association of Municipal Employees (AME-White Collar)
Base pay
$63,098
Overtime
$44,863
Other pay
$2,477
Benefits
$0
Total compensation
$110,437
Hire date
2001-09-04

Source-specific fields

Fid
750
Terminate
0

Maria Barber is a 0206C - Senior Account Clerk at Sheriff within Association of Municipal Employees (Ame-White Collar). They have served since 2001 (about 23 years). 2024 total compensation came to $110,437.

Peter Brown

5501C - Correction Officer I/Sheriff

2024 total comp
$110,289
Sub-department
Correction Officers Association (COA)
Base pay
$81,945
Overtime
$19,782
Other pay
$8,563
Benefits
$0
Total compensation
$110,289
Hire date
2016-12-26

Source-specific fields

Fid
1762
Terminate
0

At Sheriff, Peter Brown serves as a 5501C - Correction Officer I within Correction Officers Association (Coa). Their tenure dates to 2016, about 8 years. Their 2024 pay totaled $110,289.

Jeff Micari

0765C - Office Systems Analyst II/Sheriff

2024 total comp
$109,363
Sub-department
Association of Municipal Employees (AME-White Collar)
Base pay
$92,308
Overtime
$8,007
Other pay
$9,048
Benefits
$0
Total compensation
$109,363
Hire date
2008-11-17

Source-specific fields

Fid
10106
Terminate
0

At Sheriff, Jeff Micari serves as a 0765C - Office Systems Analyst II within Association of Municipal Employees (Ame-White Collar). Hired in 2008, they have about 16 years of service. Their 2024 pay totaled $109,363.

Peter Clark

5501C - Correction Officer I/Sheriff

2024 total comp
$108,910
Sub-department
Correction Officers Association (COA)
Base pay
$69,556
Overtime
$31,740
Other pay
$7,614
Benefits
$0
Total compensation
$108,910
Hire date
2019-01-14

Source-specific fields

Fid
2963
Terminate
0

At Sheriff, Peter Clark serves as a 5501C - Correction Officer I within Correction Officers Association (Coa). Hired in 2019, they have about 5 years of service. Their 2024 pay totaled $108,910.

Klurissa Watkins

5501C - Correction Officer I/Sheriff

2024 total comp
$108,680
Sub-department
Correction Officers Association (COA)
Base pay
$77,434
Overtime
$23,013
Other pay
$8,232
Benefits
$0
Total compensation
$108,680
Hire date
2017-09-25

Source-specific fields

Fid
16037
Terminate
0

At Sheriff, Klurissa Watkins serves as a 5501C - Correction Officer I within Correction Officers Association (Coa). They have served since 2017 (about 7 years). Their 2024 pay totaled $108,680.

David Hablenko

5501C - Correction Officer I/Sheriff

2024 total comp
$108,652
Sub-department
Correction Officers Association (COA)
Base pay
$73,556
Overtime
$25,967
Other pay
$9,130
Benefits
$0
Total compensation
$108,652
Hire date
2018-05-14

Source-specific fields

Fid
6373
Terminate
0

David Hablenko is a 5501C - Correction Officer I at Sheriff within Correction Officers Association (Coa). Their tenure dates to 2018, about 6 years. 2024 total compensation came to $108,652.

Anthony Russo

5501C - Correction Officer I/Sheriff

2024 total comp
$108,545
Sub-department
Correction Officers Association (COA)
Base pay
$69,556
Overtime
$29,140
Other pay
$9,849
Benefits
$0
Total compensation
$108,545
Hire date
2019-01-14

Source-specific fields

Fid
13423
Terminate
0

At Sheriff, Anthony Russo serves as a 5501C - Correction Officer I within Correction Officers Association (Coa). Their tenure dates to 2019, about 5 years. Their 2024 pay totaled $108,545.

Samantha Appel

5501C - Correction Officer I/Sheriff

2024 total comp
$107,957
Sub-department
Correction Officers Association (COA)
Base pay
$79,160
Overtime
$20,432
Other pay
$8,364
Benefits
$0
Total compensation
$107,957
Hire date
2017-09-25

Source-specific fields

Fid
564
Terminate
0

At Sheriff, Samantha Appel serves as a 5501C - Correction Officer I within Correction Officers Association (Coa). Hired in 2017, they have about 7 years of service. Their 2024 pay totaled $107,957.

Lenneke Symes

0177C - Public Safety Dispatcher I/Sheriff

2024 total comp
$107,780
Sub-department
Association of Municipal Employees (AME-White Collar)
Base pay
$84,326
Overtime
$14,869
Other pay
$8,585
Benefits
$0
Total compensation
$107,780
Hire date
2008-12-29

Source-specific fields

Fid
15114
Terminate
0

At Sheriff, Lenneke Symes serves as a 0177C - Public Safety Dispatcher I within Association of Municipal Employees (Ame-White Collar). Hired in 2008, they have about 16 years of service. Their 2024 pay totaled $107,780.

Barton Traylor

5501C - Correction Officer I/Sheriff

2024 total comp
$107,329
Sub-department
Correction Officers Association (COA)
Base pay
$54,041
Overtime
$33,010
Other pay
$20,278
Benefits
$0
Total compensation
$107,329
Hire date
1995-10-10

Source-specific fields

Fid
15235
Terminate
11453.95
Termination Date
Jul 10, 2024

Barton Traylor holds the role of 5501C - Correction Officer I at Sheriff within Correction Officers Association (Coa). Their tenure dates to 1995, about 29 years. In 2024, their total compensation was $107,329.

Refat Asanov

5501C - Correction Officer I/Sheriff

2024 total comp
$107,128
Sub-department
Correction Officers Association (COA)
Base pay
$56,609
Overtime
$40,778
Other pay
$9,741
Benefits
$0
Total compensation
$107,128
Hire date
2022-05-16

Source-specific fields

Fid
614
Terminate
0

Refat Asanov holds the role of 5501C - Correction Officer I at Sheriff within Correction Officers Association (Coa). They have served since 2022 (about 2 years). In 2024, their total compensation was $107,128.

Kevin Gray

5501C - Correction Officer I/Sheriff

2024 total comp
$107,041
Sub-department
Correction Officers Association (COA)
Base pay
$66,280
Overtime
$30,391
Other pay
$10,370
Benefits
$0
Total compensation
$107,041
Hire date
2019-07-29

Source-specific fields

Fid
6151
Terminate
0

At Sheriff, Kevin Gray serves as a 5501C - Correction Officer I within Correction Officers Association (Coa). Hired in 2019, they have about 5 years of service. Their 2024 pay totaled $107,041.

Frank Braccia

5501C - Correction Officer I/Sheriff

2024 total comp
$107,030
Sub-department
Correction Officers Association (COA)
Base pay
$77,422
Overtime
$21,376
Other pay
$8,232
Benefits
$0
Total compensation
$107,030
Hire date
2017-09-25

Source-specific fields

Fid
1232
Terminate
0

Frank Braccia works as a 5501C - Correction Officer I for Sheriff within Correction Officers Association (Coa). Their tenure dates to 2017, about 7 years. Frank earned $107,030 in 2024.

Richard Agostini

0905C - Administrator II/Sheriff

2024 total comp
$106,868
Sub-department
Association of Municipal Employees (AME-White Collar)
Base pay
$100,592
Overtime
$3,800
Other pay
$2,477
Benefits
$0
Total compensation
$106,868
Hire date
2001-06-25

Source-specific fields

Fid
70
Terminate
0

At Sheriff, Richard Agostini serves as a 0905C - Administrator II within Association of Municipal Employees (Ame-White Collar). Hired in 2001, they have about 23 years of service. Their 2024 pay totaled $106,868.