City of Buffalo / Police B District / Police Lieutenant

Job-title file

Police Lieutenant

Enforce laws and maintain public safety — patrol, respond to incidents, investigate crimes, and make arrests.

17 employees hold this title in Police B District. Median total compensation for the role is $129,556, above the department median of $106,587.

Employees: 17
Role median: $129,556
Agency median: $106,587
Comparison: Above

What the records show

Role pay distribution

Pay distribution for this role

$176$215,894+

How total compensation varies among the 17 people in this role. Even for one job title, pay differs with seniority, step, overtime, and tenure. Each bar is a pay range; the far-right bar collects the highest earners.

Record list

Employees with this title

Highest-paid first / page 1

Michael Long

Police Lieutenant/Police B District

2026 total comp

$223,889

Sub-department: PUBLIC SAFETY
Base pay: $70,811
Overtime: $112,633
Other pay: $40,445
Benefits: $0
Total compensation: $223,889

Source-specific fields

Employeeid: 83320

Michael Long is a Police Lieutenant at Police B District within Public Safety. 2026 total compensation came to $223,889.

Marquest Castillo

Police Lieutenant/Police B District

2026 total comp

$198,905

Sub-department: PUBLIC SAFETY
Base pay: $91,005
Overtime: $81,396
Other pay: $26,504
Benefits: $0
Total compensation: $198,905

Source-specific fields

Employeeid: 172545

At Police B District, Marquest Castillo serves as a Police Lieutenant within Public Safety. Their 2026 pay totaled $198,905.

Garrett O'Neill

Police Lieutenant/Police B District

2026 total comp

$180,849

Sub-department: PUBLIC SAFETY
Base pay: $78,417
Overtime: $57,344
Other pay: $45,088
Benefits: $0
Total compensation: $180,849

Source-specific fields

Employeeid: 172572

Garrett O'Neill is a Police Lieutenant at Police B District within Public Safety. 2026 total compensation came to $180,849.

Courtney Tripp

Police Lieutenant/Police B District

2026 total comp

$177,510

Sub-department: PUBLIC SAFETY
Base pay: $93,418
Overtime: $60,683
Other pay: $23,409
Benefits: $0
Total compensation: $177,510

Source-specific fields

Employeeid: 172868

At Police B District, Courtney Tripp serves as a Police Lieutenant within Public Safety. Their 2026 pay totaled $177,510.

Adam O'Shei

Police Lieutenant/Police B District

2026 total comp

$159,946

Sub-department: PUBLIC SAFETY
Base pay: $83,924
Overtime: $33,461
Other pay: $42,561
Benefits: $0
Total compensation: $159,946

Source-specific fields

Employeeid: 168098

Adam O'Shei is a Police Lieutenant at Police B District within Public Safety. 2026 total compensation came to $159,946.

Joseph Mullen

Police Lieutenant/Police B District

2026 total comp

$148,722

Sub-department: PUBLIC SAFETY
Base pay: $88,169
Overtime: $26,520
Other pay: $34,034
Benefits: $0
Total compensation: $148,722

Source-specific fields

Employeeid: 170256

Joseph Mullen holds the role of Police Lieutenant at Police B District within Public Safety. In 2026, their total compensation was $148,722.

Aaron Young

Police Lieutenant/Police B District

2026 total comp

$141,211

Sub-department: PUBLIC SAFETY
Base pay: $112,644
Overtime: $0
Other pay: $28,566
Benefits: $0
Total compensation: $141,211

Source-specific fields

Employeeid: 160020

Aaron Young is a Police Lieutenant at Police B District within Public Safety. 2026 total compensation came to $141,211.

Shawn Mccabe

Police Lieutenant/Police B District

2026 total comp

$138,838

Sub-department: PUBLIC SAFETY
Base pay: $80,954
Overtime: $27,268
Other pay: $30,616
Benefits: $0
Total compensation: $138,838

Source-specific fields

Employeeid: 173211

Shawn Mccabe is a Police Lieutenant at Police B District within Public Safety. 2026 total compensation came to $138,838.

Vincent Judge

Police Lieutenant/Police B District

2026 total comp

$129,556

Sub-department: PUBLIC SAFETY
Base pay: $92,317
Overtime: $13,848
Other pay: $23,392
Benefits: $0
Total compensation: $129,556

Source-specific fields

Employeeid: 172557

Vincent Judge holds the role of Police Lieutenant at Police B District within Public Safety. In 2026, their total compensation was $129,556.

Joshua Domros

Police Lieutenant/Police B District

2026 total comp

$125,395

Sub-department: PUBLIC SAFETY
Base pay: $88,645
Overtime: $12,480
Other pay: $24,270
Benefits: $0
Total compensation: $125,395

Source-specific fields

Employeeid: 173042

Joshua Domros holds the role of Police Lieutenant at Police B District within Public Safety. In 2026, their total compensation was $125,395.

Jeffrey Giallella

Police Lieutenant/Police B District

2026 total comp

$116,865

Sub-department: PUBLIC SAFETY
Base pay: $14,949
Overtime: $24,329
Other pay: $77,588
Benefits: $0
Total compensation: $116,865

Source-specific fields

Employeeid: 51680

Jeffrey Giallella is a Police Lieutenant at Police B District within Public Safety. 2026 total compensation came to $116,865.

Michael Haas

Police Lieutenant/Police B District

2026 total comp

$115,430

Sub-department: PUBLIC SAFETY
Base pay: $79,574
Overtime: $5,275
Other pay: $30,580
Benefits: $0
Total compensation: $115,430

Source-specific fields

Employeeid: 172554

Michael Haas works as a Police Lieutenant for Police B District within Public Safety. Michael earned $115,430 in 2026.

Larry Muhammad

Police Lieutenant/Police B District

2026 total comp

$115,042

Sub-department: PUBLIC SAFETY
Base pay: $0
Overtime: $0
Other pay: $115,042
Benefits: $0
Total compensation: $115,042

Source-specific fields

Employeeid: 172774

At Police B District, Larry Muhammad serves as a Police Lieutenant within Public Safety. Their 2026 pay totaled $115,042.

Caryn Anderson

Police Lieutenant/Police B District

2026 total comp

$106,774

Sub-department: PUBLIC SAFETY
Base pay: $0
Overtime: $0
Other pay: $106,774
Benefits: $0
Total compensation: $106,774

Source-specific fields

Employeeid: 172541

Caryn Anderson holds the role of Police Lieutenant at Police B District within Public Safety. In 2026, their total compensation was $106,774.

Darren Exum

Police Lieutenant/Police B District

2026 total comp

$37,942

Sub-department: PUBLIC SAFETY
Base pay: $1,574
Overtime: $0
Other pay: $36,369
Benefits: $0
Total compensation: $37,942

Source-specific fields

Employeeid: 164327

Darren Exum holds the role of Police Lieutenant at Police B District within Public Safety. In 2026, their total compensation was $37,942.

Michael Delong

Police Lieutenant/Police B District

2024 total comp

$284

Sub-department: PUBLIC SAFETY
Base pay: $0
Overtime: $133
Other pay: $152
Benefits: $0
Total compensation: $284

Source-specific fields

Employeeid: 165026

At Police B District, Michael Delong serves as a Police Lieutenant within Public Safety. Their 2024 pay totaled $284.

Paul Flanagan

Police Lieutenant/Police B District

2024 total comp

$176

Sub-department: PUBLIC SAFETY
Base pay: $0
Overtime: $77
Other pay: $99
Benefits: $0
Total compensation: $176

Source-specific fields

Employeeid: 46260

Paul Flanagan is a Police Lieutenant at Police B District within Public Safety. 2024 total compensation came to $176.