New York City / Office of Collective Bargainin

Agency file

Office of Collective Bargainin

Source file: New York City — Citywide Payroll / ingested Jun 18, 2026

The Office of Collective Bargainin is a government agency that delivers public services and programs within its jurisdiction.

In 2025, this agency had 15 employees with median total compensation of $154,578; the highest distinct record was $277,813.

Year: 2025
Employees: 15
Median total: $154,578
Highest record: $277,813

What the records show

Compensation analytics

These summaries compare pay within the agency before listing individual records.

Salary distribution

$79,711$277,813+

How 2025 total compensation is spread across the 15 employees. Each bar is a pay range; taller bars mean more people earn in that range. The amber line marks the median ($154,578) — half earn less, half more. The far-right bar collects the highest earners.

Average pay composition

Base — $162,922 (100%)
Overtime — $0 (0%)
Other — $244 (0%)
Benefits — $0 (0%)

What an average paycheck here is made of — base salary versus overtime, other pay (bonuses, allowances), and benefits. A large overtime or other-pay share means take-home often exceeds base salary.

Pay percentiles

10th

25th

Median

75th

90th

$84,224

$133,157

$154,578

$192,612

$246,042

The pay ladder for this department. Someone at the 90th percentile earns $246,042 — more than 90% of the department; the 10th percentile earns $84,224. The shaded band is the middle half of employees (25th–75th percentile).

Largest job titles

Labor Relations Trial Examiner

5 · $154,578

Deputy Director

2 · $236,519

Director of the Office of Collective Bargaining

1 · $277,813

Director of Information and Research

1 · $206,683

Administrative Staff Analyst

1 · $187,106

The most common job titles in this department by headcount, with the median total compensation for each. Click a title to see everyone who holds it.

Record list

Employees

Highest-paid first / page 1

Susan Panepento

Director of the Office of Collective Bargaining/Office of Collective Bargainin

2025 total comp

$277,813

Base pay: $276,813
Overtime: $0
Other pay: $1,000
Benefits: $0
Total compensation: $277,813
Hire date: 2001-03-19
Pay basis: Annual
Work city: MANHATTAN
Middle name: J

Source-specific fields

Base Salary: $286,627
Leave Status as of June 30: Active
Overtime Hours: 0
Payroll Number: 313
Regular Hours: 1,820

Susan Panepento holds the role of Director of the Office of Collective Bargaining at Office of Collective Bargainin based in Manhattan. They have served since 2001 (about 24 years). In 2025, their total compensation was $277,813.

Monu Singh

Deputy Director/Office of Collective Bargainin

2025 total comp

$246,042

Base pay: $246,042
Overtime: $0
Other pay: $0
Benefits: $0
Total compensation: $246,042
Hire date: 2015-09-09
Pay basis: Annual
Work city: MANHATTAN

Source-specific fields

Base Salary: $259,158
Leave Status as of June 30: Active
Overtime Hours: 0
Payroll Number: 313
Regular Hours: 1,820

Monu Singh works as a Deputy Director for Office of Collective Bargainin based in Manhattan. They have served since 2015 (about 10 years). Monu earned $246,042 in 2025.

Steven Star

Deputy Director/Office of Collective Bargainin

2025 total comp

$226,995

Base pay: $226,246
Overtime: $0
Other pay: $749
Benefits: $0
Total compensation: $226,995
Hire date: 2015-09-07
Pay basis: Annual
Work city: MANHATTAN
Middle name: E

Source-specific fields

Base Salary: $234,267
Leave Status as of June 30: Active
Overtime Hours: 0
Payroll Number: 313
Regular Hours: 1,820

Steven Star holds the role of Deputy Director at Office of Collective Bargainin based in Manhattan. They have served since 2015 (about 10 years). In 2025, their total compensation was $226,995.

Karine Spencer

Director of Information and Research/Office of Collective Bargainin

2025 total comp

$206,683

Base pay: $206,290
Overtime: $0
Other pay: $393
Benefits: $0
Total compensation: $206,683
Hire date: 2003-04-21
Pay basis: Annual
Work city: MANHATTAN
Middle name: C

Source-specific fields

Base Salary: $213,604
Leave Status as of June 30: Active
Overtime Hours: 0
Payroll Number: 313
Regular Hours: 1,820

Karine Spencer holds the role of Director of Information and Research at Office of Collective Bargainin based in Manhattan. Hired in 2003, they have about 22 years of service. In 2025, their total compensation was $206,683.

Abigail Levy

Labor Relations Trial Examiner/Office of Collective Bargainin

2025 total comp

$192,612

Base pay: $192,612
Overtime: $0
Other pay: $0
Benefits: $0
Total compensation: $192,612
Hire date: 2011-02-28
Pay basis: Annual
Work city: MANHATTAN
Middle name: R

Source-specific fields

Base Salary: $199,441
Leave Status as of June 30: Active
Overtime Hours: 0
Payroll Number: 313
Regular Hours: 1,820

Abigail Levy works as a Labor Relations Trial Examiner for Office of Collective Bargainin based in Manhattan. They have served since 2011 (about 14 years). Abigail earned $192,612 in 2025.

Melissa Trasky

Administrative Staff Analyst/Office of Collective Bargainin

2025 total comp

$187,106

Base pay: $187,106
Overtime: $0
Other pay: $0
Benefits: $0
Total compensation: $187,106
Hire date: 1997-09-29
Pay basis: Annual
Work city: MANHATTAN
Middle name: A

Source-specific fields

Base Salary: $193,739
Leave Status as of June 30: Active
Overtime Hours: 0
Payroll Number: 313
Regular Hours: 1,820

Melissa Trasky is a Administrative Staff Analyst at Office of Collective Bargainin based in Manhattan. Hired in 1997, they have about 28 years of service. 2025 total compensation came to $187,106.

Peter Zwiebach

Labor Relations Trial Examiner/Office of Collective Bargainin

2025 total comp

$156,670

Base pay: $155,670
Overtime: $0
Other pay: $1,000
Benefits: $0
Total compensation: $156,670
Hire date: 2024-01-29
Pay basis: Annual
Work city: MANHATTAN
Middle name: L

Source-specific fields

Base Salary: $162,619
Leave Status as of June 30: Active
Overtime Hours: 0
Payroll Number: 313
Regular Hours: 1,820

At Office of Collective Bargainin, Peter Zwiebach serves as a Labor Relations Trial Examiner based in Manhattan. Hired in 2024, they have about a year of service. Their 2025 pay totaled $156,670.

Nora Sullivan

Labor Relations Trial Examiner/Office of Collective Bargainin

2025 total comp

$154,578

Base pay: $154,578
Overtime: $0
Other pay: $0
Benefits: $0
Total compensation: $154,578
Hire date: 2023-04-11
Pay basis: Annual
Work city: MANHATTAN
Middle name: L

Source-specific fields

Base Salary: $161,586
Leave Status as of June 30: Active
Overtime Hours: 0
Payroll Number: 313
Regular Hours: 1,820

Nora Sullivan holds the role of Labor Relations Trial Examiner at Office of Collective Bargainin based in Manhattan. Hired in 2023, they have about 2 years of service. In 2025, their total compensation was $154,578.

Brian Zapert

Labor Relations Trial Examiner/Office of Collective Bargainin

2025 total comp

$152,982

Base pay: $152,982
Overtime: $0
Other pay: $0
Benefits: $0
Total compensation: $152,982
Hire date: 2022-01-09
Pay basis: Annual
Work city: MANHATTAN
Middle name: H

Source-specific fields

Base Salary: $158,406
Leave Status as of June 30: Active
Overtime Hours: 0
Payroll Number: 313
Regular Hours: 1,820

Brian Zapert is a Labor Relations Trial Examiner at Office of Collective Bargainin based in Manhattan. Their tenure dates to 2022, about 3 years. 2025 total compensation came to $152,982.

Alexander Menkin

Computer Systems Manager/Office of Collective Bargainin

2025 total comp

$145,629

Base pay: $145,629
Overtime: $0
Other pay: $0
Benefits: $0
Total compensation: $145,629
Hire date: 2012-07-09
Pay basis: Annual
Work city: MANHATTAN

Source-specific fields

Base Salary: $150,792
Leave Status as of June 30: Active
Overtime Hours: 0
Payroll Number: 313
Regular Hours: 1,820

Alexander Menkin is a Computer Systems Manager at Office of Collective Bargainin based in Manhattan. Their tenure dates to 2012, about 13 years. 2025 total compensation came to $145,629.

Kyle Brewster

Labor Relations Trial Examiner/Office of Collective Bargainin

2025 total comp

$133,157

Base pay: $133,157
Overtime: $0
Other pay: $0
Benefits: $0
Total compensation: $133,157
Hire date: 2020-07-07
Pay basis: Annual
Work city: MANHATTAN
Middle name: C

Source-specific fields

Base Salary: $140,420
Leave Status as of June 30: Active
Overtime Hours: 0
Payroll Number: 313
Regular Hours: 1,820

At Office of Collective Bargainin, Kyle Brewster serves as a Labor Relations Trial Examiner based in Manhattan. Their tenure dates to 2020, about 5 years. Their 2025 pay totaled $133,157.

John Stevens

Executive Assistant to the Director/Office of Collective Bargainin

2025 total comp

$118,914

Base pay: $118,398
Overtime: $0
Other pay: $516
Benefits: $0
Total compensation: $118,914
Hire date: 2020-07-07
Pay basis: Annual
Work city: MANHATTAN
Middle name: R

Source-specific fields

Base Salary: $122,596
Leave Status as of June 30: Active
Overtime Hours: 0
Payroll Number: 313
Regular Hours: 1,820

John Stevens works as a Executive Assistant to the Director for Office of Collective Bargainin based in Manhattan. Their tenure dates to 2020, about 5 years. John earned $118,914 in 2025.

Carrie Brown

Secretary to the Director of Collective Bargaining/Office of Collective Bargainin

2025 total comp

$84,376

Base pay: $84,376
Overtime: $0
Other pay: $0
Benefits: $0
Total compensation: $84,376
Hire date: 2016-01-11
Pay basis: Annual
Work city: MANHATTAN
Middle name: A

Source-specific fields

Base Salary: $87,367
Leave Status as of June 30: Active
Overtime Hours: 0
Payroll Number: 313
Regular Hours: 1,820

Carrie Brown works as a Secretary to the Director of Collective Bargaining for Office of Collective Bargainin based in Manhattan. They have served since 2016 (about 9 years). Carrie earned $84,376 in 2025.

Zolanny Valerio

Secretary to the Deputy Chair/Office of Collective Bargainin

2025 total comp

$84,224

Base pay: $84,224
Overtime: $0
Other pay: $0
Benefits: $0
Total compensation: $84,224
Hire date: 2013-04-01
Pay basis: Annual
Work city: MANHATTAN

Source-specific fields

Base Salary: $87,210
Leave Status as of June 30: Active
Overtime Hours: 0
Payroll Number: 313
Regular Hours: 1,820

At Office of Collective Bargainin, Zolanny Valerio serves as a Secretary to the Deputy Chair based in Manhattan. They have served since 2013 (about 12 years). Their 2025 pay totaled $84,224.

Vanessa Success

Community Associate/Office of Collective Bargainin

2025 total comp

$79,711

Base pay: $79,711
Overtime: $0
Other pay: $0
Benefits: $0
Total compensation: $79,711
Hire date: 2023-07-03
Pay basis: Annual
Work city: MANHATTAN
Middle name: N

Source-specific fields

Base Salary: $82,600
Leave Status as of June 30: Active
Overtime Hours: 0
Payroll Number: 313
Regular Hours: 1,820

Vanessa Success is a Community Associate at Office of Collective Bargainin based in Manhattan. Their tenure dates to 2023, about 2 years. 2025 total compensation came to $79,711.